Political Innovation is Needed to Catch Up with Student Anger

Posted on November 15, 2010 by | 10 Comments

I attended the Political Innovation Conference in Edinburgh on Saturday. It was interesting, and a very well planned day in an excellent venue. Following what I suspect may be a defining week in UK politics I was keen to hear what the collected bloggers and Twitter-ers had to say about the role of social media in defining our political future.
The Informatics forum worked very well as a flexible (if cold) space to conference in. It was great to meet Mick Fealty, whose “Slugger O’Toole” blog is genuinely groundbreaking. It provides a cross community resource that has raised the quality of debate in Northern Ireland politics. It’s read every day by most members of the Northern Ireland Assembly, and regularly breaks news stories.

Several themes came out of the day. The first was that the Obama campaign has become mesmeric for social media and new campaigns. The second is that the Tea Party is now the touchstone for debate around campaigns. Thirdly, there are a lot of nationalists out there angry about their marginalisation in the Scottish media. Lastly, it seems that the change in the political context marked by the ‘Demolition’ rally in London last week has had very little impact on what young people involved in politics think about politics.

All three sessions I attended had discussions circling around both the Obama campaign and the Tea Party movement. Broadly people approve of the Obama campaign and are quite frightened by the Tea Party. The conclusion was that the Obama campaign used social media to mobilise and excite the people most likely to get active in the campaign. These people then used traditional techniques, like door knocking, to get out the vote. That seems right to me. There’s an unfortunate caucus which believes that election campaigns can be won on the internet.

Similarly, the Tea Party uses social media to bring those together who believe in economic libertarian and neo-conservative politics together into a coalition. This has been successful in getting a slate of radical right-wingers elected, like Rand Paul. I’m quite sure that this is in part because of the way Obama has closed his government down to the movement that elected him. The appointment of Rahm Emmanuel was disastrous – describing supporters of the “Public Option” in Health Reform as “f**king retarded” reflects his opinions on the movement that elected Obama. It shows that if you get elected using sword of social media you need also to live by that sword.

Mick Fealty made a fascinating point, drawing on blogger Burke’s Corner, about how the USA was a Whig state, and that tradition means there is great scepticism about government. Which is why the USA swings to the right. Meanwhile Canada was a Tory state, happier with government, but consequently swinging to the left. This has profound implications for the current government’s sceptical approach to government. Fundamentally the left in the UK believes it has successfully captured the state, which now must be defended. That may play well with the traditionally Tory polity in the UK, which eventually ousted Thatcher.

The event was dominated by nationalist bloggers. They’re right that the issue of independence is unfairly treated by the Scottish media. There are few pro-independence columnists, and the tabloid media treats the concept in a deeply partisan and deeply Unionist way. But it’s not the only issue on which the Scottish media gets it wrong. There are a whole range of other issues where the Mainstream Media are totally ineffective. Anyone who honestly thinks the release of Abdelbaset Ali Mohmed Al Megrahi is of comparable political significance to the Irish economic collapse (as one contributor did) clearly has no sense of political proportion.

There has been no serious debate on the additional Forth Road Bridge. When the Scottish Parliament’s Finance Committee attacked the Scottish Information Commissioner in 2007 the Scottish media couldn’t be bothered to cover the story. Weeks later the Westminster media broke a very similar story – which was massive. Sadly too many of the nationalist bloggers are happy with the media hegemony on these issues. There’s more to politics than the national question, and the case for more powers would be stronger if it were less one dimensionally put by nationalist bloggers.

Most interesting was the attitude of many of the younger people in some of the sessions. While I’d seen the events in London as evidence that young people are anything but apathetic, the conversation worked from an assumed position that young people are more apathetic. For an event that was meant to be about political innovation this was deeply disappointing. If you think innovation in politics is taking a marketing approach, or making it more like “The X-Factor” then we’re faced with a pretty dire future. The poverty of analysis was matched only by the lack of ambition. The problem with politics is precisely that it is bedevilled by a marketing approach and failed attempts to be like “The X-Factor.” The managerial politics of the last 20 years, marked by an ever more presidential style, has gone a long way to killing politics. If you never discuss anything interesting you make politics boring.

The really sad thing about this is that the people at the event should have been excited by the strength of the protest in London, and by people caring about politics. Instead they dismissed it as transient and superficial while prescribing what were transparently transient and superficial solutions. It was really deeply disheartening to see how deeply the cynicism of the Blair years has seeped into the collective political psyche.

I’m still optimistic that the students radicalised by the Conservative-Liberal Democrat attack on students and young people will be able to reverse this essentially hope-free approach to politics. There’s certainly every chance they will, given just how brutal the attack on today’s young people is. That’s what the conversation I had in the pub was about. And because it’s so easy to get a blog up and running I’m hoping some of the righteously angry will be at the next Political Innovation conference kicking the hopeless and unambitious out.

Be Sociable, Share!


10 Responses to “Political Innovation is Needed to Catch Up with Student Anger”

  1. Lallands Peat WorrierNo Gravatar
    November 15th, 2010 @ 1:46 pm

    Its a point I have significant sympathy with, Peter. Obviously, folk will have different positions on particular ideas, projects, policies structures – but I think you’re right that railing against a unionistic press establishment risks insufficiently generalising the many ways in the press’ analytic frame actually operates, what it marginalises & privileges.

    This touches on the related but I think distinct issues of press capacity – literally their ability to understand, engage with, summarise and encourage meaningful discussion on the gamut of “political topics” – & the extent to which discriminating values are involved, where stories which could be written aren’t.

  2. Peter McCollNo Gravatar
    November 15th, 2010 @ 2:44 pm

    I think it’s a sad reflection on the one-dimensional nature of many blogs (present company excepted, of course). Too often the discussions on Saturday were those that the cynic might expect from bloggers. There was a lot of opinionating and people talking past one another or hijacking conversations for their own preoccupations. The nationalist bloggers were just the most prominent.

    It was interesting that Pat Kane, who’d arrived late and expected a discussion of ‘cybernats’ was left almost speechless when he discovered he was the first to use the term.

    You’re quite right about press capacity. Though I do wish the Scottish press would run fewer stories about the Scottish Parliament building and expenses and more about our actual politics. It’s easier to find out what happened at a Scottish Division 3 Football match than in our parliament.

  3. BelindaNo Gravatar
    November 16th, 2010 @ 12:23 pm
  4. DominiqueNo Gravatar
    June 5th, 2014 @ 12:26 am

    Included in a marketing plan is the advertising and promotional methods to be used and a study
    of the proposed effectiveness of the methods.
    Just how can I sign up with a free of charge affiliate program.
    Business owners need to understand the needs and wants of their demographic market; how they access information; and
    the types of advertisements they respond to.

  5. http://menuo.free.Fr/?p=56885No Gravatar
    July 2nd, 2014 @ 4:28 pm

    free paypal account with money

  6. https://mcpvp.zendesk.com/entries/52063600-Programming-Your-Depths-Of-The-Mind-In-Five-Easy-StepsNo Gravatar
    August 20th, 2014 @ 5:08 am

    My partner and I stumbled over here different website and thought I should check things out.
    I like what I see so now i am following you.
    Look forward to looking over your web page repeatedly.

    Make certain to address each risk’s likelihood of occurring in addition to
    its impact about the project and the organization. In order to inspire a quick moving and excited feeling within the mind of reader, you are able
    to use various techniques. Does harry and
    david ship internationally above – https://mcpvp.zendesk.com/entries/52063600-Programming-Your-Depths-Of-The-Mind-In-Five-Easy-Steps – Tip 1:
    Always write clearly, and determine what message you would
    like to communicate within your copy. Let say as an example we
    have calculated that this team can deliver 30 story
    points inside a 2 week iteration and you can find 240 story
    points to supply (now defined inside contract).

  7. online dating toolNo Gravatar
    September 5th, 2014 @ 1:07 am

    Hello There. I discovered your weblog the usage of msn. This is
    an extremely well written article. I’ll make sure to
    bookmark it and return to read more of your helpful info.
    Thank you for the post. I’ll certainly return.


  1. Political Innovation, Edinburgh and changing politics? « Slugger O'Toole
  2. Political Innovation is Needed to Catch Up with Student Anger … | Conservative Government
  3. A Scottish Political Innovation? » Peter Geoghegan's Blog